SUTTONS BAY TOWNSHIP

PLANNING COMMISSION

Wednesday, August 2, 2006-6:30 p.m.

Suttons Bay Township Office

 

CALL TO ORDER:  Meeting Called to order at 6:33 p.m.

 

ROLL CALL: Chair Jerry Bergman, Commissioners: Doug Periard, Cristal Guinan, Jeff Corbin, Shirley Wall, Tom Nixon, Jon Walter.  Absent Don Gregory and Ron Send.  Quorum Established.  Corbin questioned Send missing more then three consecutive meetings.

 

STAFF PRESENT:  Rochelle Rollenhagen and Steve Patmore.

 

GUESTS:  There were four guests present.

 

APPROVAL OF THE AGENDA:  Bergman stated that Thorntree Commons had asked to be removed from the agenda.

 

MOVE BY WALL SUPPORT BY CORBIN TO APPROVE THE AGENDA AS AMENDED.

AYES 7, Nays-0, Absent-2 Motion Carried

 

APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES: Patmore asked that the minutes be tabled for approval until next month.

 

PUBLIC COMMENT: None

 

PUBLIC HEARING-REZONE OF PARCELS 45-011-025-051-00, 045-011-036-007-00 AND 45-011-036-006-00 located at 1008 S Lake Leelanau Drive from the Agricultural District to Residential Zoning District.

 

Planner Rollenhagen discussed the conditions that were mentioned last month.  She stated that applicant Susan Nichols has presented in a letter dated August 1, 2006 and read into the record that they would support a conditional rezoning.  Rollenhagen pointed out that if the applicant failed to meet the conditions, the property would revert back to the previous district.

 

Wall questioned if the property was sold would the rezone stand.  Patmore stated it would and that the new property owners would be bound by the same conditions.

 

Dave Christianson spoke on behalf of the applicants.  He stated that the property consisted of 2000 feet of frontage with 22 existing structures.  He added that there would be 13-15 structures in three different areas, for a total of 39-45 units.  They had hoped to allow for 50 feet of frontage per structure. 

 

Patmore stated that the proposed conditions -clustering of the development and no multi family dwellings would address the previous concerns of the commissioners.  The commissioners agree that it was unlikely this property would be used for agricultural purposes in the future.

 

Rochelle pointed out that the commission was presented with rezoning factors to consider that the Township attorney had provided as well as the proposed Ordinance to allow for a rezone.

 

Public hearing closed at 7:05 p.m.

 

MOVE BY NIXON SUPPORT BY GUINAN TO ACCEPT THE REZONE FACTORS DATED AUGUST 2, 2006 AS THE FINDINGS OF FACT FOR THE REZONE OF THE ABOVE MENTIONED PROPERTIES.

AYES 7, Nays-0, Absent-2 Motion Carried

 

MOVE BY WALTERS SUPPORT BY NIXON TO RECOMMEND TO THE TOWNSHIP BOARD THAT THEY ADOPT ORDINANCE ___ OF 2006 SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS:

 

1.                  That the Development of the property under Residential Zoning shall be performed under Article X of the Suttons Bay Township Zoning Ordinance and;

2.                  Development of the property under residential zoning shall not include multi-family dwellings (more then 2 units per building).

 

AYES 7, Nays-0, Absent-2 Motion Carried

 

 

SITE PLAN REVIEW VINEYARD INN:

 

Patmore indicated that the applicants, Pam Leonard and Steve Kozelko had presented a site plan requesting to remodel two existing units, add 792 sq feet for a tasting room, reconfigure the parking and add a 25 x 30 storage building (later amended to state 30 x 40).  Patmore added that the Township board had approved a license for the tasting room earlier this year.

 

Pam Leonard spoke and restated their request.  Parking was discussed as well as issues with the site distance and M-22 configuration.  Leonard indicated that the operation would be seasonal.

 

MOVE BY WALTER SUPPORT BY CORBIN TO APPROVE THE SITE PLAN AS PRESENTED (WITH CHANGE IN STORAGE BUILDING) WITH THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS: 

1.      Drainage plans must be submitted and approved by the Leelanau County Drain Commissioner/Soil Erosion Officer

2.      Applicant is responsible to obtain any and all permits for the building necessary to perform the work.

3.      Applicant must obtain a Land Use Permit for the Buildings from the Suttons Bay Township Zoning Administrator.

4.      Any exterior lighting shall be directed downward and shall conform to the zoning ordinance.

5.      The existing sign is grandfathered; however, sandwich Board signs are prohibited for commercial businesses.

6.      The trash/dumpster shall be screened.

7.      Vehicles shall not be allowed to park along M-22 or impede access on Pebble Beach Drive.  The owner shall be responsible to provide additional parking or limit the number of vehicles should problems arise.

 

Housekeeping –Zoning Ordinance Amendments:

 

Rochelle presented the commission with amendments to Article III, and Article V that addresses the Office Transition District and Article IV that removes Cluster Housing as a special use in the Agricultural District and allows it as a Use Permitted with Conditions.

 

MOVE BY WALL SUPPORT BY CORBIN TO APPROVE THE HOUSEKEEPING LANGUAGE AS PRESENTED AND TAKE THE AMENDMENTS TO A PUBLIC HEARING NEXT MONTH.

AYES 7, Nays-0, Absent-2 Motion Carried

 

 

Office Transition District-County Planning Comments:

 

Rollenhagen and Patmore stated that county planning had reviewed the office transition district and offered some definitions that they felt should be incorporated.  Rochelle will forward the comments to the commissioners for discussion next month.

 

Master Plan-Intent to Plan:

 

Rollenhagen stated that the Master Plan was due for review and would like the commissions support on sending a letter of intent to plan to the neighboring townships and County.

 

MOVE BY WALL SUPPORT BY CORBIN TO AUTHORIZE ROLLENHAGEN TO FILE A STATEMENT OF INTENT TO PLAN WITH THE APPROPRIATE ENTITIES.

AYES 7, Nays-0, Absent-2 Motion Carried

 

 

 

 

 

Planning Commission Priorities:

 

The commission members discussed the following priorities:

  • Conditional Rezoning Language
  • Buffering/Landscaping
  • Parking
  • Short Term Rental
  • Junk Ordinance
  • Key holing

 

The commission members asked Rollenhagen to prepare a list as well as staff time required to draft and implement the proposed language.

 

By Law Changes:

 

Rochelle and Steve stated that they were recommending changes to the By-laws:

 

  • Change the ending of the meeting time from 9:00 p.m. to 8:30 p.m. and indicate that no additional action items to be addressed after 2 hours from the start of the meeting unless requested by the commission so all reports could be heard.

 

  • Add No July meeting

 

  • Re-arrange the agenda and provide for a Conflict of Interest Statement

 

  • Under Minutes-Record all minutes and destroy tape after approval of the minutes.

 

  • Public Comment to be placed above Public hearings

 

MOVE BY CORBIN SUPPORT BY WALTER TO AMEND THE BY-LAWS AS SUGGESTED THIS EVENING.

AYES 7, Nays-0, Absent-2 Motion Carried

 

Reports:

 

Zoning Administrator:

 

Patmore presented his written report.  Patmore added that he had received a notice of intent to file a referendum regarding the Office Transition District.

 

Patmore added that the Walter rezone has been approved and the Bertram rezone has been tabled and is requesting a “voluntary condition.”

 

 

 

Planner:

 

Rollenhagen stated that she hoped to have the updated Ordinance ready and online in the next few weeks.

 

Zoning Ordinance Committee:  No Report

Township Board Report: No Report

 

Chairman’s Perspective:  The chairman thanked the staff for all their hard work in helping the meetings flow.

 

PUBLIC COMMENT:

 

Bob Chamberlain discussed that while housekeeping amendments were being made the commission could be addressing impervious surfaces in Article XII.

 

Chamberlain also discussed FOIA as it relates to the By-Laws, the Office Transition District and Strip Development potential.

 

MOVE BY WALTER SUPPORT BY NIXON TO ADJOURN THE MEETING

AYES 7, Nays-0, Absent-2 Motion Carried

 

Meeting Adjourned at 8:17 p.m.

Respectfully Submitted

 

Dorothy Petroskey

Recording Secretary